The MLB’s recent foray into celebrity culture has backfired spectacularly, costing the league millions in subscribers and brand partnerships. What began as a well-intentioned attempt to blend pop culture with America’s pastime has, instead, alienated many of its most loyal fans.

It all started on October 14, when pop sensation Taylor Swift and NFL star Travis Kelce were seen together at Game 1 of the ALCS in New York. The MLB, eager to capitalize on the star power of Swift, swiftly flooded their social media channels with posts and TikTok videos of the couple enjoying the game. The MLB even took to over-the-top captions, one of which read, “TAYLOR SWIFT ATTENDS GAME WITH HER POTENTIAL FUTURE HUSBAND,” followed by the overly sentimental “YOU TWO MAKE ME BELIEVE IN LOVE. I CAN’T STOP CRYING. NEVER CHANGE. ILYSM.”

Fans, however, were far from amused. The MLB’s attempt to showcase Swift’s celebrity status as a way of luring in new fans was met with a swift backlash. “This is baseball, not a rom-com!” one fan tweeted. Others were less kind, with comments like, “Stick to sports. We don’t care who’s dating who!” and “Are we at a baseball game or a love story audition?”

The MLB’s gamble to bring Swift and Kelce into the spotlight was undoubtedly an effort to attract a broader audience. Swift’s massive following, especially on social media, was seen as an opportunity to introduce new eyes to baseball. But rather than gaining new fans, the league lost over 1.5 million subscribers to its streaming platforms, as baseball purists were turned off by the shift in focus from the game to celebrity gossip.

Further complicating matters, several of the league’s high-profile sponsors pulled back or canceled agreements. One major beverage company reportedly walked away from a $5 million deal, expressing concern that the MLB was straying too far from its core fan base, who are more interested in the sport than the latest pop culture trends.

“This isn’t The Bachelor, it’s baseball,” said marketing expert Lisa Thompson. “The MLB has forgotten that their fans come for the game, not for celebrity romance.”

The fallout from the MLB’s celebrity-driven experiment has left the league scrambling. Insiders report that the MLB is reassessing its strategy, dialing down the celebrity content and considering how to win back the fans who felt alienated by the Swift-Kelce spectacle.

Some see this as a cautionary tale, with one sports analyst, Jake Morrison, commenting, “Baseball doesn’t need pop stars to stay relevant. It needs exciting games and real rivalries.” Another said, “The MLB tried to appeal to a different demographic, but they forgot the number-one rule of sports marketing: know your audience.”

The league’s attempt to blend the world of sports with pop culture has raised questions about how far it should go in catering to celebrities. While bringing in star power can generate buzz, it can just as easily backfire if it alienates the heart of the fan base. After all, sports fans want to see plays, not headlines.

Swift and Kelce’s relationship, meanwhile, continues to make waves, but the MLB’s brief flirtation with celebrity culture seems to have hit a sour note. Fans have made it clear they prefer the focus to be on the game, not the gossip.

The moral of this story is simple: no amount of star power can replace the appeal of a good game. For the MLB, this misstep serves as a lesson that it may be best to stick to what it knows best—promoting baseball, not the celebrity drama surrounding it. As one fan put it, “Taylor Swift may sell out stadiums, but she can’t sell baseball. Let’s keep them separate.”

In the end, the MLB may have learned the hard way that celebrity crossovers don’t always translate into success in the world of sports. Going forward, it seems the league would be wise to focus on what truly matters to fans—exciting plays, memorable moments, and the game itself.